Foreign Perspectives

I see that the Information Commissioner would like breaches of the magnitude seen this week made a criminal offense.

But if it were so right now, who would be the person being arrested by the police? Would it be the “junior official” who appears to have made an error in using a courier firm rather than the Royal Mail. Yet, at the time he would have been told NOT to use the Royal Mail as they were planning to go on strike that week.

In such instances, the instructions are to use courier services instead and that’s just what he did.

Many people have said that such a junior official should never have been responsible for so many records yet that’s the reality of day to day operations in large government departments. Quite junior people need to be able to work with all the records in that way. Surely no-one is expecting the head of HMRC to run the programs that process the various benefits himself?

Short of getting in the car and driving down to London with the CDs, just how could he have gotten the information to London? Yes, there is encrypted e-mail between government departments but it’s just not up to e-mailing two CDs full of information. After all, normal e-mail systems usually can’t even e-mail a single digital photograph these days.